|
Sexual Health Exchange, 1998 - no. 1
Sexual and physical abuse: a threat to reproductive and sexual health
Naira Khan
Cross-cultural data confirm that violence - whether sexual, physical or emotional - has two fundamental certainties: first, the overwhelming majority of perpetrators are men; and, second, the targets are usually women. The startling reality is that women have no place of safety from abuse. They are at risk in the so-called safety of their homes where they may be physically battered or become victims of (marital) rape. When they step out into the street, they are at further risk for rape, date rape and verbal harassment. At the workplace, they are at risk for sexual harassment that can range from verbal harassment to sexual assault.
Nonetheless, this should not detract from the reality that a burgeoning literature recognizes violence against other vulnerable groups, including adults with alternative sexual lifestyles and children. Sexual and physical abuse subsume a wide variety of violent behaviours, only some of which are legally recognized as criminal acts.
The most invisible of all is child sexual abuse, well illustrated by research conducted in secondary schools in Harare, Zimbabwe. In a sample of 549 pupils, 30% reported they had been sexually abused; half were male children being abused by female perpetrators. The invisibility of the crime was confirmed by the fact that only 18% of the children ever told anyone that they had been or were being sexually abused.
Why are men violent towards women?
There appears to be no simplistic response to this question. Violence against women is so pervasive and tenacious that one cannot attribute it simply to individual pathology or lack of communication between partners. One of the most important tenets of violence or abuse is that an individual may perpetrate an act of violence, but the act takes place within a socio-cultural context with multiple influences.
At the societal level, inequalities between women and men need to be examined, such as legal, religious, economic and physical power inequalities. It is these inequalities that underlie our social understanding of gender and sexuality and have a profound effect on intimate relationships between men and women.
At another level, cultural norms and expectations about behaviours of women and men lead to myths that perpetuate violence and deny assistance to its victims. The myths support all forms of violence as illustrated by examples from case files in Zimbabwe. These myths, too, invade the beliefs of our families, friends, health-care workers, law enforcement agents and the justice system, which tends to compound, rather than relieve, the damaging consequences of male violence.
Who are the perpetrators?
One particular "myth" that requires concerted intervention concerns the perpetrators of violence. People find it difficult to believe that perpetrators of both sexual and physical violence are a heterogenous group and know no barriers of culture, race, occupational group, religion or socio-economic status.
Although much of the psychological research on perpetrators of violence is unclear at present, there is one consistent finding: a large majority of perpetrators are socialized for violence. Research strongly suggests that boys are more likely to abuse an intimate partner in adult life if they were themselves abused as children or adolescents. Being abused or witnessing abuse socializes children to perpetuate these behaviours. Are we all not guilty of it in some form in our homes? Do we not socialize daughters to be submissive and compliant and sons to be warriors?
In addition, a contributory role is played by the media. For example, in countries where sadistic pornography becomes readily available, the prevalence of attempted and completed rape increases. Issues of violence need to be addressed at a societal and individual level if the cycle is to be broken. Powerful social factors such as male socialization, peer pressure, the media and the military virtually breed violent behaviour in men.
The effects of violence on sexual and reproductive health
Sadly, the consequences are multiple and long-lasting. The chronic physical consequences of rape include STDs and HIV infection. Other direct reproductive health impacts of violence include unwanted pregnancy, miscarriage, unsafe abortion as well as homicide and suicide of women in cultures where rape and/or unwed pregnancy are highly stigmatized.
With respect to the psychological consequences of sexual abuse, one important factor is that the symptoms usually unfold over time. The most common symptoms include anxiety, depression, sexual dysfunction and difficulties with interpersonal relationships. This clearly points to a need for the long-term management of victims of sexual abuse. Victims of childhood sexual violence begin intercourse earlier than others, are more likely to use drugs and alcohol, and are less likely to practise contraception.
Let me conclude by reiterating that no one wakes up one morning and becomes a rapist; it is a long, slow process and includes emotions such as disrespect, a need to feel powerful or in control, and discordant ideas of human sexuality. We need to begin by addressing these issues in our own homes.
Common myths related to sexual violence abuse
Myth: Women enjoy it
Rape: Women say no when they mean yes.
Physical violence: Women don't leave abusive men so it can't be that bad, they obviously love it.
Sexual harassment: She invited it and was obviously flattered by the attention.
Myth: She asked for it
Rape: She should not have been wearing those shorts or walking on that road on her own.
- Physical violence: All she ever does is nag and she's always refusing to have sex.
- Sexual harassment: She kept working late when she knew I was around.
Myth: Men are not responsible for what happened
Rape: He did not mean it, he was just so horny.
Physical violence: He had a terrible day at the office and she was not acting like a wife.
Sexual harassment: She should be flattered, he was just showing some interest in her.
Myth: Women are not harmed
Rape: She wasn't a virgin anyway.
Physical violence: For God's sake, it's not as if her bones were broken.
Sexual harassment: She wasn't injured, I just asked her out.
Myth: These are one-off acts of violence
Rape: He was drinking and lost control of himself.
Physical violence: He was just under a lot of stress at work.
Sexual harassment: My wife is a cold-hearted bitch and I was just looking for comfort.
Action Programme on Child Sexual Abuse
Research in Zimbabwe done in 1996 revealed the following statistics:
- 70% of sexually-abused victims (all girls) were below 13 years of age
- 60% of perpetrators were younger than 20 years
- 9% of perpetrators were strangers
- 29% of perpetrators were family members or relatives
- 29% of perpetrators were lodgers
- 39% of attacks took place in the victims' homes
- 66% of cases took about one year to reach the courts
- 57% of cases had enough evidence for a conviction
Naira Khan, Co-ordinator, Project Research and Public Education on Sexual Harassment at the Workplace & Child and Law Project: Information and Prevention of Child Sexual Abuse, Training and Research Support Centre, 47 Van Praagh Ave., Milton Park, Harare, Zimbabwe; Tel: 263-4-705-108; Fax: 263-4-737-220; e-mail: nabeel@harare.iafrica.com
|