Royal Tropical Institute - Koninklijk Instituut voor de Tropen
KIT Information  & Library Services
line_white
 Exchange on HIV/AIDS, Sexuality and Gender
line_white
 English edition
 Edition française
 Edição portuguesa
 Archive

Back 

Sexual Health Exchange, 1998 - no. 2

Challenging men to reject gender stereotypes

John K. Gokova

Living in a patriarchal society, I ask myself questions. Why do I as a man have so many privileges? If men are equal in standing to women, they also profit - for example, through shared responsibility and more freedom to express themselves. That is why circumstances keeping women back must be eliminated.

The term "gender" is not synonymous for "women" but is often used in that way. The view that gender issues only concern women has served as an excuse to avoid addressing the gender stereotypes that have imprisoned men and women. Moreover, men have taken little, if any, interest in responding to the challenges women have been raising over the years. Nevertheless, gender issues demand men's participation since men need to change to realize overall change.

Men have allowed themselves to dominate or ignore reproductive rights, parenting, and active participation in family-planning matters instead of sharing those responsibilities. Many women are largely denied the freedom to decide whether they can have children or not. Ending domestic violence must become men's reponsibility. They should further see themselves as partners in addressing the problem of other men's lack of interest and concern about educating one another about their role in HIV/AIDS awareness education.

982oudemMen of all ages have sexual health needs that need to be addressed through a gender-based approach (photo: WHO)

 

The implication of all this is that men need to change their attitude towards sex. They should begin to see it as an opportunity to communicate mutually with women rather than as a chance to dominate and conquer. Men must consciously take the decision to think and behave differently.

Generally, men enjoy privileges associated with gender roles assigned to them at the expense of women. Why then do they find special privileges necessary when they claim to be stronger, braver and more creative and intelligent than women? One soon realizes that men have been living a myth that needs to be challenged. Padare/Enkundleni/Men's Forum on Gender (Padare), an antisexist organization for men in Zimbabwe, encourages men to respond to gender inequality in our society. Its message is clear: men must welcome women's invitation to help create a gender-sensitive society. To enjoy being truly human and to build a just society, men must recognize women as equal partners.

    "My wife and I decided not to raise our daughters according to the prevailing norms. We want to show them life as it should be. That means that they see daddy cooking, changing nappies and making the bed. They see me washing dishes and my wife going to work every day. Do you know what I really liked? A few days ago my 5-year-old daughter asked: 'Daddy, why do you both wear pants but not dresses?' My daughter is beginning to look around her. It was an important question for her and I was happy she asked it." John Gokova

Disadvantages of patriarchy

Men have not realized how much they pay in insisting on separate gender roles. Patriarchy forces men, whether they are aware of it or not, to be collaborators in a system that oppresses women. Men deny themselves the experience of being human, particularly insofar as their relationship with women is concerned. They miss important lessons of life derived from challenging relationships in which women play an equal role.

Padare's objectives

  • Create a forum for men to question and reject gender stereotypes and roles that privilege men and oppress women.
  • Create a support group for men who are committed to change.
  • Enable men to identify and challenge structures and institutions perpetuating gender inequality in our society.

Living the myth of male superiority has sometimes resulted in men suffering from stress, even early death, because of pressure to project an image that is not naturally theirs and that is not sustainable. For example, men cannot openly express themselves. They are not supposed to cry or admit weaknesses in the presence of women.

The separation of gender roles also restricts male creativeness. In Zimbabwe and most countries in Southern Africa, for example, men are not supposed to work in the kitchen as this is considered women's domain. Expression of love is also limited in the sense that they cannot make their girlfriends, wives, sisters or mothers a nice meal for fear of being misunderstood as compromising their "manhood."

One other assumption also needs to be challenged. So often when we talk about gender inequality we think of heterosexual people. The concept of gender should also apply equally to gay men and lesbian women. While their sexual orientation is a departure from heterosexual definitions, some of them remain imprisoned in stereotyped gender roles in their relationships. This has resulted in violence and abuse in gay communities.

Effecting change

Gender consciousness focuses on the assumptions about and roles that both men and women play. Of particular concern are the roles that men have played over the years as these have generally been associated with power and prestige. The challenge is for men to develop new role models that match those of women who are demanding recognition and respect as individuals (rather than as persons with an identity derived from their relationship with some man - the father, brother, boyfriend or husband).

    Gender refers to widely shared ideas and expectations (norms) about women and men: ideas about "typically" feminine and masculine characteristics and abilities and expectations about how women and men should behave in various situations. These ideas and expectations are learned from families, friends, opinion leaders, religious and cultural institutions, schools, the workplace and the media. They reflect and influence the different roles, social status, economic and political power of women and men in society.

What men need to do is to come together and talk, talk, talk about the way they have been raised. What assumptions about women and men have we picked up that have made us oppressive and unhelpful in creating meaningful relationships between men and women? Where do we need to change?

Men who are involved in this process need to be more visible in society. Padare encourages men to recognize and reject destructive assumptions and perceptions that result in gender inequality. Out of this process, a new definition of manhood is emerging. Men are understanding that the gender struggle is not about lifting women to the position of men. After all, men have been elevated to a super-human position through patriarchy and the tensions that result from such a life of pretense are quite high, unhealthy and unsustainable for men and society in the long term.

Men need to cooperate with women who have been working on gender issues, sometimes in isolation and sometimes dealing with hostile men threatened by the prospect of change. For example, many times men in Zimbabwe have stood in the way of women's access to information that is likely to increase their knowledge and status. Cooperation will allow men to help rather than block that access.

Our vision for the creation of a society established on gender justice requires the involvement of every man and woman. We recognize, however, that men have a particular responsibility in this effort. Men need to be challenged continually to seek change. This means openly and publicly rejecting the current image of manhood. Developing a new man whose existence does not depend on any form of violence and abuse of women is possible!

    "Older men especially find it difficult to change their way of thinking. It is a part of their life that is now being questioned. But I still maintain that people can change. You can change yourself and look for people who believe the same way you do. Inequality doesn't just exist in Zimbabwe. I think that patriarchal thinking prevails in most societies. The problems we have here also exist in other countries. There, too, men could organize themselves and address the prevailing way of thinking." John Gokova

John K. Gokova, Padare/Enkundleni/Men's Forum on Gender, P.O. Box 1524, Harare, Zimbabwe; Tel/fax: 163-4-796-685; email: ess@mango.zw


Topexchange@kit.nl   © Royal Tropical Institute