|
Sexual Health Exchange, 1998 - no. 4
Impact of peer education on HIV infection in Zimbabwe
Mary Bassett
SubSaharan Africa is presently the region of the world most severely affected by the global HIV/AIDS pandemic. Zimbabwe bears one of the heaviest burdens of HIV/AIDS in the world, with an estimated 25% of sexually-active adults being HIV positive. The epidemic's effects are already being felt, but the full impact is yet to come. Identification of effective, affordable and sustainable interventions is therefore an urgent public health priority.
Peer education offers a potentially powerful, affordable means of delivering health education messages to communities. By identifying members of the target group to serve as educators and condom distributors, communities are mobilized to help themselves. Because this approach relies on existing human resources rather than technology or extensive use of specialists, it is likely to be a relatively affordable and sustainable intervention. Despite the fact that peer education has been widely promoted, however, it has not been examined rigorously using a randomized trial or HIV infection as an end-point. For these reasons, the Zimbabwe AIDS Prevention Project (ZAPP) decided to undertake a randomized trial of peer education.
Peer education at the workplace
The workplace offers access to an economically important population that is at risk of HIV infection. Earlier work by ZAPP had shown that about 20% of the male workforce was HIV positive. Among those who were HIV negative, 3% acquired HIV infection each year. Independent risk factors for becoming HIV positive included: a history of genital ulcers, having multiple partners, and being married but living apart from the spouse. These findings indicated that health education promoting partner reduction and condom use - if successful in achieving behaviour change - would greatly reduce risk of HIV infection.
In 1993, ZAPP began enrolling men at 40 participating factories in Harare, Zimbabwe's capital city. Workers were eligible to enrol if they were 18 years or older and able to give consent to participation in the study. As participants, ZAPP enrollees agreed to answer a brief questionnaire and to undergo testing for syphilis, hepatitis B virus and HIV every six months. A ZAPP clinic was established to provide counselling, testing and STD treatment. Enrolment proceeded over a period of several years.
In June 1994, ZAPP offered 20 randomly selected factories a peer education intervention. Four factories declined to participate in peer education because of the time that would be involved, so four additional factories were selected from the comparison group. The nonpeer education factories continued to be offered counselling, testing and adequate condom supplies at six-monthly visits.
Peer educators were selected at each workplace and trained using a syllabus developed by the Matabeleland AIDS Council (MAC) and a teaching module from AMREF Tanzania. Training took place over one week and covered the role of the peer educator, the world HIV/AIDS epidemic, STD symptoms and treatment, HIV transmission, prevention and care. After the initial training, the peer educators met at sixmonth intervals to attend refresher courses.
The minimum peer educator goals were to: have one peer educator for every 100 workers, maintain a continuous supply of free condoms at work sites, and organize at least one drama and two presentations by persons living with HIV/AIDS (one man and one woman). Peer educators also led discussions, showed videos and slide shows.
Evaluating the intervention
HIV incidence was compared between factories where peer education was implemented and those where no peer education was offered. Incidence was measured by counting the number of new HIV infections (seroconversions) among those known to be HIV negative at the time peer education was introduced. Because participants were enrolled in the ZAPP study for varying periods, the amount of time each participant was enrolled was used as the denominator (persontime). Incidence was compared in two ways: first, the incidence for all individuals enrolled in "intervention" and "control" factories was compared; next, the overall incidence at each factory was compared using a statistical test.
A total of 2219 men were documented as being HIV negative after peer education was introduced; 78% completed at least one followup. The overall incidence of HIV infection was 2.52 per 100 person years. This is equivalent to 2.52%/year. When the time to HIV infection for all individuals enrolled in the cohort at "intervention" factories was plotted against the "control" factories, it showed that the peer education factories had fewer new HIV infections than the control factories. The difference was statistically significant.
Research findings
The findings of this study support the conclusion that peer education reduces the incidence of HIV among factory workers. To our knowledge, this is the first randomized trial to assess a health education strategy that has used acquisition of HIV as its measure of effectiveness. Very few randomized trials have been conducted in developing countries. A notable exception was a communitybased study of STD treatment in a rural and partly peri-urban Tanzanian setting. This important study showed a 40% reduction in HIV infection.
Another behavioural intervention is voluntary counselling and testing for HIV. Counselling and testing were made available to all participants, whether or not they worked at a factory selected for peer education. Consequently, this study assessed the impact of peer education over and above the impact of counselling and testing for HIV, an intervention shown to contribute to behaviour change in other settings.
ZAPP's evaluation study has concluded that peerled health education with condom distribution and aggressive treatment of STDs should form the foundation of HIV prevention policy and the standard of care for the evaluation of further interventions in developing countries.
Dr Mary Bassett, Senior Lecturer, Department of Community Medicine, University of Zimbabwe Medical School, and Director, Zimbabwe AIDS Prevention Project (ZAPP), 103105 Rotten Row, Harare, Zimbabwe; Tel: 2634752-167; Fax: 2634749-865; email: mary@zapp.uz.co.zw |