Royal Tropical Institute - Koninklijk Instituut voor de Tropen
KIT Information  & Library Services
line_white
 Exchange on HIV/AIDS, Sexuality and Gender
line_white
 English edition
 Edition française
 Edição portuguesa
 Archive

Back 

Sexual Health Exchange 2003-3

Treatment preparedness in Eastern Europe: the need for international co-operation

Mauro Guarinieri

As in other parts of the developing world, access to antiretroviral treatment in the countries of Eastern European and the Newly Independent States (EE/NIS) is still limited. Likewise, the treatment advocacy and literacy movement in this region is still very weak. The European AIDS Treatment Group, Europe's oldest network on access to treatment issues, is currently expanding to these countries, in order to assist in the building up of treatment preparedness in the region.

Although initially isolated from the global HIV pandemic by draconian Soviet restrictions on contact with foreigners and harsh social control, there has been a growing epidemic in Eastern Europe since the mid-1990s. The first outbreaks were reported in 1995 among injecting drug users in Odessa and Mikolayev in southern Ukraine. They were rapidly followed by other drug-related HIV outbreaks, notably in the Russian territory of Kaliningrad in 1996, and a few months later in other regions of the Russian Federation (Krasnodar, Rostov on Don, Tver) and in neighbouring Belarus and Republic of Moldova.

Since then, the situation has continued to grow rapidly worse, affecting more regions and countries. UNAIDS and WHO stated that, with an estimated 1.2 million HIV-positive individuals at the end of 2002 (compared to only 30,000 at the start of 1995), Eastern Europe and Central Asia are the regions of the world with the fastest growing HIV epidemic. Russia is facing an HIV epidemic of such proportions that the World Bank predicts that, unless the government quickly undertakes pragmatic prevention and treatment interventions, the Russian economy will suffer tremendously.

There are big differences in wealth and poverty, HIV prevalence and access to treatment between the Eastern European countries of the Warsaw Pact (e.g., Romania, Bulgaria) and the Newly Independent States that were once part of the Soviet Union, such as Ukraine, Belarus and Russia. Since a total of 291 million people live in the EE/NIS region, 1.2 million means that 0.6% of the adult population is HIV-positive. The average national spending on health care per capita in these states ranges from US$ 16 to US$ 181 per year. Only a couple of thousand people are using antiretroviral therapy. According to the Central and Eastern European Harm Reduction Network (CEE-HRN, see Box), countries where injecting drug users make up two-thirds or more of the total number of HIV/AIDS cases provide almost no ARV treatment at all, and if treatment is available, injecting drug users are often excluded. Existing barriers to access to care and treatment include inadequate government policies, high costs of drugs, and lack of technical capacity and appropriate infrastructure to manufacture and distribute these drugs.

One step beyond

Scaling up ARV therapy goes beyond the mere availability of antiretroviral medicines: also issues such as infrastructure, skills-building of health-care providers, and treatment education of patients, their families and the larger public is necessary in order to ensure safe and high-quality use of ARVs and increased usage. So far, limited efforts have been undertaken in the EE/NIS region to prepare the community and PLWHA for antiretroviral treatment. Among others, there is a high need for treatment education.

Recent research in the US showed that HIV-infected people with lower health literacy levels had lower CD4 cell counts, higher viral loads, were less likely to be taking antiretroviral medications, reported a greater number of hospitalisations, and reported poorer health than those with higher health literacy levels. Treatment literacy for both health-care providers and PLWHA is essential if we expect treatment to be effective. Treatment literacy for the government and the public is also essential. Knowledge that effective treatment exists will alleviate the fear and stigma associated with AIDS and encourage people to learn about HIV, and utilise counselling, testing, care and support services. Finally, science represents our greatest advocacy tool. Advocates' efforts are supported by scientific evidence that confirms the importance of health literacy in maintaining the well-being of PLWHA. To be effective and develop sound policies, advocates should first learn, understand and disseminate scientific knowledge on HIV/AIDS.

The European AIDS Treatment Group

The European AIDS Treatment Group (EATG) was founded in 1991 as a group of people affected by HIV/ AIDS in Europe and concerned about treatment issues. Over 100 people from 20 different countries are individual members, and the majority work for AIDS Service Organisations in their own countries. The EATG was the first, and is still the only, pan-European organisation advocating for the interests of PLWHA on treatment issues in Europe.

From 3-5 October 2003, the EATG held a regional conference on Access to Treatment and Harm Reduction in Kiev, Ukraine. The seminar was designed and organised in full cooperation with the All-Ukrainian Network of People Living with HIV/AIDS. The meeting provided advocacy and treatment literacy training, and allowed participants to further develop their advocacy agenda and strategise toward the implementation of that agenda. This seminar was part of a broader strategy undertaken by the EATG to give technical assistance and support to the growing PLWHA advocacy movement in Eastern Europe.

With the primary aim of mobilising most of its resources to Eastern Europe and the Newly Independent States, the European AIDS Treatment Group established a new working group in May 2003 to coordinate all EATG action in this region. The objectives of this EATG Eastern European States Working Group are to:

    -Advocate for greater involvement of PLWHA in the EE/NIS region in all decision-making processes

    -Push for the rights of all those living with HIV/AIDS, with a special focus on drug users, gay men, sex workers, women, inmates etc. to access treatment

    -Acknowledge and address the existence of discrimination within the PLWHA and larger AIDS advocacy community, specifically around populations such as injecting drug users, refugees and sex workers

    -Empower its members from the region to develop the regional policy priorities and recruit other organisations in the region to join the EATG

    -Offer annual or semi-annual "train the trainers" treatment education seminars in the region and set up a clearinghouse of information in Russian

    -Assist its members in advocating for the registration of generic drugs and to campaign for this where it is possible

    -Work with its members to ensure that good and sound treatment plans to cover all aspects of HIV/AIDS care, including antiretroviral treatment, palliative care, psychosocial care and treatment and prevention of opportunistic infections are included in the national AIDS strategies of these countries

    -Endorse the use of methadone and other substitution therapy as an issue of access to essential medicines.

The development and dissemination of treatment education materials and training specifically designed and culturally adapted to meet the needs in the region will represent a crucial component of our ambitious programme. The European AIDS Treatment Group does not consider ‘stand-alone' trainings, where a group from a developed nation comes in, provides some brief training and then leaves, useful and cost-effective. The need to provide ongoing support and have training tied to longer-term efforts will be thus essential to meet the above mentioned goals.

The HIV epidemic arrived in Eastern Europe later than in other parts of the world. This gives the region a unique potential and the opportunity to take advantage of lessons (as well as of the many mistakes) already learned by the global community and to prevent the death toll that has been seen in other parts of the world. Although this potential has still to be realised, actions must be promptly undertaken to increase treatment literacy, capacity building and community mobilisation to secure the region free and universal access to treatment and good health for those living with HIV/AIDS.

Mauro Guarinieri, Chairperson European AIDS Treatment Group; Mindener Strasse 33, 40227 Düsseldorf, Germany; tel.: +49-211-788.34.81, fax: +49-211-788.54.14, e-mail: mauro@eatg.org, web: www.eatg.org

This article was produced by Mauro Guarinieri on behalf of the EATG Eastern European States Working Group. More information on this newly established working group: Svilen Konov, conov@lycos.com.

Access to ARV and exclusion of drug users in Eastern Europe and Central Asia

In its report Injecting Drug Users, HIV/AIDS treatment and primary care in Central and Eastern Europe and the Former Soviet Union, the Central and Eastern European Harm Reduction Network (CEE-HRN) states that injecting drug users (IDUs), who form the biggest part of PLWHA in the region, have the least access to antiretroviral therapy.

ARV access for PLWHA is greatest in countries where IDUs are the smallest percentage of HIV/AIDS cases; countries where IDUs are two-thirds or more of total cases provide almost no ARV of any kind, or exclude IDUs from the little treatment available. Overall, IDUs account for 82% of all HIV/AIDS cases in the region, but only 23% of those receiving antiretroviral medicines. In Belarus, where 78% of HIV/AIDS cases are IDUs, none are using combination therapy. While IDUs are 93% of cases in Russia, programmes report that only 13% of those receiving triple combination therapy are IDUs. In Ukraine, 20 out of 24 programmes including government HIV/AIDS and harm reduction programmes alike report that IDUs are informally discouraged or prohibited from receiving care.

These data come from a survey of 132 organisations in Central and Eastern Europe and the countries of the former Soviet Union, which assessed the accessibility of among others HIV medications for injecting drug users in the region in May 2002. Organisations surveyed included harm reduction programmes and government HIV/AIDS programmes such as national, regional or municipal AIDS centres, a well as UN agencies.

Other findings include that access to ARVs of any kind, particularly triple combination therapy, is highly limited for all PLWHA across the region. Respondents in 24 countries in this region reported that less than 7,000 people – 2% of registered HIV/AIDS cases - were receiving triple combination therapy. However, more than three-quarters of these were living in only two countries, Romania and Poland. In the European Newly Independent States (Belarus, Moldova, Russia and Ukraine), the countries where HIV prevalence and incidence is highest, only 0.3% of PLWHA who are registered received triple therapy in 2002. No ARV of any kind was available in countries such as Albania, Azerbaijan and Tajikistan.

More information: Anya Sarang, CEE-HRN; Vilniaus St. 25-7a, 2600 Vilnius, Lithuania; tel.: +370-5-269.16.00, fax: +370-5-261.14.89, e-mail: info@ceehrn.org, web: www.ceehrn.org

Injecting Drug Users, HIV/AIDS treatment and primary care in Central and Eastern Europe and the Former Soviet Union, CEE-HRN, 2002, www.ceehrn.lt/EasyCEE/sys/files/CEE-HRN.EN.pdf

 

  [


Topexchange@kit.nl   © Royal Tropical Institute