|
Sexual Health Exchange 2004-1
Bridging the gaps between religion and sexual and reproductive health and rights
The role of faith-based organisations in Africa
Nicola Ward, Rehana Kader & Musa Dankyau
Many FBOs play a crucial role in the provision of health care in African communities. However, the ambiguities between the official positions of the religious leaders on SRHR issues and the needs they encounter within the communities hinder their ability to provide appropriate and comprehensive sexual and reproductive health services. For instance, doctors in a mission hospital in sub-Saharan Africa might have difficulties in educating their HIV-infected patients to prevent infection of their partners, as the church forbids them to promote condom use. This ambiguity often forces FBOs to take action in influencing the religious hierarchies in which they operate to discuss sexual and reproductive health and rights (SRHR). Being close to the religious structures in which they operate gives them a unique opportunity to bridge the gap between the international protocols on SRHR and existing religious laws.
The following examples of organisations have been chosen to show how FBOs can successfully create change, working within their own religious contexts, to increase access to SRHR. One example is taken from South Africa of an FBO working in Muslim communities; the second example is taken from Nigeria of an FBO working in Christian communities.
Positive Muslims
Positive Muslims is a South African (Cape Town) based FBO for Muslim people living with HIV/AIDS founded in 2000. The majority of the Muslim community, including some of its leadership, perceive HIV/AIDS to be a punishment from God for having immoral lifestyles and having sinned. Positive Muslims challenges the Muslim leaders and Islamic policies towards those infected with HIV through direct community action and research with such groups in the community. One of their members has also spoken publicly about her positive status and the issues she faces as being part of the Muslim community.
Positive Muslims offers individual counselling, home visits and hospital visits. They also run a fortnightly support group for male and female Muslims living with or affected by HIV/AIDS. Some issues that are discussed within the support group include the wish to have children, loss of a child either through AIDS or due to complications during pregnancy, and relationships and HIV. Some women have difficulties discussing such issues in the presence of men and even their partners. Women also face problems when seeking advice from the Muslim clergy as they feel "judged" by them, firstly for being HIV positive and secondly for talking about sex-related matters while the Muslim clergy tends to be male.
The support group aims to overcome some of these barriers by encouraging open discussions between men and women in the group. There are also three Muslim religious leaders who regularly participate in discussions. Through this process they now openly address HIV/AIDS issues in their mosques. This is a significant change, as it was previously forbidden to talk about these issues in mosques. The women and men participating in the support group have emphasised the need and usefulness of such a service, as well as the fact that they feel more accepted, respected and recognised as Muslims who are living with HIV/AIDS.
Another example of the influence Positive Muslims has had on religious hierarchies concerns the issue of condom use before marriage. This is traditionally forbidden, as in Islam sex before marriage is not allowed. However, the Muslim religious leaders involved in the discussions have drastically changed their views on this issue through continual dialogue with Positive Muslims and involvement in other awareness raising activities. Many Muslim leaders will now discuss these issues in the mosque as well.
ECWA – Evangelical Churches of West Africa
ECWA is a faith-based organisation involved in community programmes in Northern Nigeria. Programme activities include: theological education, media and information, work within hospitals, with Challenge bookshops and Challenge cinema. They also run a pharmacy, printing press and radio station amongst others. They address a variety of sexual and reproductive health issues in the communities where they work through the involvement of church leaders. One SRH issue that is being addressed in the Christian communities is that Christians would much rather talk about reproduction than the accompanying issues of sexuality and the problems around it, e.g. frigidity, erection problems and premature ejaculation. Many Christians in Nigeria feel that sex between couples is strictly for procreation and nothing more. If procreation is not affected, then there are no problems, they argue. However, the reality faced by many Pastors and Counsellors in the church is that sexual problems are fundamental to a lot of the marital dysfunction they see among their members, but that no one was willing to talk about it.
The challenge was how to get Church members to discuss their sexuality problems and get appropriate help. ECWA approached respected theologians who were specialized in teaching and writing on the biblical reasons for marriage, to find ways of working on issues around SRHR. As a result, books, bible study materials and other pamphlets were prepared indicating the appropriate place of sexuality in marriage. The curriculum for the seminaries and theological colleges was also modified to include material on sexuality and possible problems. Local churches were stimulated to have a retreat for couples, where members are encouraged to share and seek help concerning their sexuality problems. The church also made sexuality a required section of counselling for couples intending to marry.
Out of this has grown a willingness by couples to contact their Pastor or Counsellor concerning sexual health problems they would hitherto have kept to themselves. There are also a growing number of experienced counsellors who are able and willing to help couples with these problems.
Conclusion
The work of FBOs is very challenging and it is important that they have the opportunity to share their experiences and strategies for working within their different environments. In this light International Family Health created the "African Forum of Faith-Based Organisations in Reproductive Health and HIV/AIDS"; an alliance of FBOs in Africa working in the field of sexual and reproductive health in 1999. The Forum provides an effective mechanism for FBOs to increase their capacity to become agents for change; to have a stronger voice at local, national and international levels; and to advocate for increased recognition of women's and men's rights to modern, safe, integrated and affordable sexual and reproductive health care services.
The Forum has 15 partners from 8 African countries (Nigeria, Ethiopia, Tanzania, Kenya, Uganda, Zambia, Namibia, and South Africa), including ECWA and Positive Muslims. Members receive financial support to implement a range of activities to promote the aims of the Forum. This includes leadership development training for religious leaders and FBO leaders, exchange visits, action research and technical assistance from International Family Health.
The Forum has enabled a vital discourse on SRHR issues among African faith-based institutions. The challenges to members are both to effect practical responses to sensitive issues and to impact on the way that needs are met in the communities they serve.
The work of ECWA and Positive Muslims exemplifies the key role FBOs have to play in bridging the gap between religion and sexual and reproductive rights, as they are part of the communities in which they work and respected by the religious hierarchies. FBOs have an important contribution to give in how to work within different religious contexts. The aim of the Forum has been to develop this potential and to give the space for the different FBOs to discuss and overcome barriers. In this way FBOs can join together to become a stronger force within the different religions to promote a united front when working for sexual and reproductive health and rights.
Nicola Ward, International Projects Manager, International Family Health; 1st Floor Cityside House, 40 Adler Street, London E1 1EE, United Kingdom; tel.: +44-20-724.799.44, e-mail: nward@ifh.org.uk, web: www.ifh.org.uk; Rehana Kader, Assistant Director, Positive Muslims; P.O. Box 13127, Mowbray 7705, Cape Town, South Africa; tel.: +27-21-448.76.43, fax: +27-21-448.82.41, e-mail: rehana@positivemuslims.org.za, web: www.positivemuslims.org.za; and Musa Dankyau, Director of Medical Services, ECWA; Medical HQ, 1 Noad Road, P.O. Box 63, Jos, Plateau State, Nigeria.
|
African Forum of Faith-Based Organisations in Reproductive Health and HIV/AIDS
The overall aim of the Forum is to promote dialogue on ethical and moral issues that are perceived as barriers to the active involvement of FBOs in SRH priorities. The emphasis is on identifying the tensions between the theological and ethical constructs of religious hierarchies and the expectations of, and constraints on, the role of FBOs in meeting community SRH priorities, to influence constructive change for policy and programme development.
Main objectives
v To strengthen the capacity of FBOs to initiate and lead the discourse on SRH amongst their constituencies in a faith based context.
vTo facilitate the development of tools to enable FBOs to analyse the policy and programme approaches of their organisations informed by evidence of the real and unmet SRH needs in their communities.
vBuild alliances and share learning with organisations in the South and North.
vCreate opportunities for FBOs to collectively raise awareness and understanding of SRH issues in Africa.
More information: www.ifh.org.uk/theforum.html
|
|
|